By: John Richards
The Basic Test
The question of infringement of a design patent presents a different problem from that of a utility patent, since the claim in a design patent always reads “A … as shown” or “A … as shown and described”.1 Thus, all that is to be considered in determining infringement is what can be seen and, as was emphasized in Curver Luxembourg SARL v. Home Expressions Inc2., the nature of the article set out in the claim.
As long ago as 1871, in Gorham Co. v. White,.3 the Supreme Court laid down a test for infringement of design patents in the following terms:
If, in the eye of the ordinary observer, giving such attention as a purchaser usually gives, two designs are substantially the same, if the resemblance is such as to deceive such an observer, inducing him to purchase one supposing it to be the other”, then there is infringement
The Federal Circuit has held that one must compare the ornamental features of the patented design, as shown in all the drawings, to the features of the alleged infringing product visible at any time during normal use of the product and assess if the resemblance at such point is such as to deceive … an ordinary observer, giving such attention as a purchaser usually gives.4
This is a factual question that will normally be decided by a jury after hearing evidence from both sides and the judge has explained the various legal issues that need to be taken into account discussed below to the jury.
Read full article here.
